Marlins Target $56M Alcantara Trade Amid Cy Young Fallout
The Miami Marlins' Trade Dilemma: From Star Power to Strategic Moves
The Miami Marlins have found themselves in a unique position as the trade deadline approaches. Once known for their high-profile signings and financial commitments, the team has had to reassess its strategy after a season that didn’t meet expectations. The $56 million spent on stability has led to a 7.22 ERA, leaving many to question whether the investment was worth it. Now, as teams look to bolster their rosters for the postseason, the Marlins are becoming a central hub in the trade market.
Sandy Alcantara, once considered the crown jewel of the Marlins’ rotation, is now facing scrutiny. His 2025 season has been plagued by inconsistency, with a 7.22 ERA and a career-worst 17.3% strikeout rate. Coming off Tommy John surgery, he’s viewed more as a project than a reliable playoff option. Despite his name value, Alcantara’s performance has raised concerns about his long-term viability. At $17 million annually, he represents a costly gamble for any team looking to add a starting pitcher.
In contrast, Edward Cabrera has emerged as a more attractive option in the trade market. The 27-year-old right-hander has posted a 2.54 ERA over his last 12 starts, showcasing improved control and a high-90s fastball. His 25%+ strikeout efficiency and reduced walk rate have made him a top target for teams seeking a reliable starter. While he faced some elbow fatigue earlier this season, his clean MRI has alleviated concerns, making him an appealing choice for contenders.
Cabrera’s value is further enhanced by his contract status. He’s under control through 2028 at bargain prices, which makes him a highly desirable asset. Teams like the Cubs and Tigers are reportedly interested, but they’ll need to part with top-tier prospects such as Owen Caissie, Moises Ballesteros, and major-league-ready arms like Ben Brown. For front offices, the combination of breakout stuff and years of control justifies the premium price.
While Alcantara may still carry name recognition, it’s clear that Cabrera has taken the spotlight in trade discussions. The Marlins are now positioning themselves as a key player in the market, with both pitchers available for the right package. As teams evaluate their options, the decision will come down to whether they want a proven but struggling veteran or a younger, more promising talent with long-term upside.
The Yankees’ Quiet Pursuit of Hidden Gems
While other teams are chasing big names like Alcantara and Cabrera, the New York Yankees are taking a different approach. Brian Cashman and his staff are looking beyond the headlines, focusing on players who might be overlooked but could make a significant impact. One such player is Ronny Henriquez, a 25-year-old right-handed pitcher who has quietly impressed front offices with his performance.
Henriquez has posted a stellar 2.60 ERA across 45 innings, striking out 63 batters while allowing only 35 hits. His ability to consistently throw 98 mph and maintain control has made him a valuable asset, especially for a team dealing with bullpen injuries. With Fernando Cruz battling an oblique strain and Mark Leiter Jr. sidelined with a leg fracture, the Yankees need reliable pitching to keep their World Series hopes alive.
Henriquez’s long-term control through 2030 adds to his appeal, though it also means his price tag is steep. The Yankees, known for being cautious with their prospects, may be hesitant to part with top-tier talent. However, the urgency of the situation could lead to a deal that benefits both sides. If Henriquez moves, it would be a strategic move that addresses the Yankees’ immediate needs while providing the Marlins with valuable assets.
The Importance of Quiet Performers
In the world of baseball, it’s often the flashy names that dominate the headlines. But history has shown that October success is frequently decided by the players no one talked about in July. Henriquez, much like Cabrera, represents the kind of talent that can make a difference when it matters most. His consistency, velocity, and control make him a compelling option for any team looking to strengthen its roster.
As the trade deadline approaches, the Marlins will continue to be a focal point in the market. Whether they choose to move Alcantara, Cabrera, or Henriquez, their decisions will have a ripple effect across the league. For teams like the Yankees, the challenge will be balancing short-term needs with long-term goals. In a competitive landscape where every advantage counts, the right move could be the difference between a playoff berth and a missed opportunity.